The ACL Injury Guide: Your Questions Answered

An ACL injury can stop you playing sport for many months, so it helps to have realistic expectations about the injury, surgery and recovery. This guide answers the questions patients commonly ask Dr Vishal Pai in consultations.

It covers what an ACL injury is, whether you need surgery, what surgery involves, and what to expect during rehabilitation and your return to sport.

At a Glance

  • The ACL controls rotation and front-to-back movement of the knee, and a complete tear does not heal on its own.
  • Not everyone needs surgery; it is most often recommended for younger, active people and those who play pivoting sports.
  • The main graft options are the hamstrings, patellar tendon and quadriceps tendon, each with trade-offs.
  • Rehabilitation takes at least 12 months, and returning to sport too early increases the risk of re-injury.
  • Physiotherapy is important whether or not you have surgery.

On this page

What should you know about ACL injuries?

What does ACL stand for?

ACL stands for anterior cruciate ligament. It sits inside the knee joint and controls rotation and front-to-back movement of the knee.

Diagram of the knee showing a torn anterior cruciate ligament.
An ACL injury

Where do you feel pain with an ACL injury?

The pain of an ACL injury is felt inside the knee. People often describe a tearing feeling or a pop at the time of injury. The knee usually swells soon afterwards because of bleeding from the torn ligament, and the swelling can take weeks to settle.

Is an ACL rupture the same as a tear?

An ACL tear can be partial, which is uncommon, or complete. A complete ACL tear is the same as an ACL rupture.

Can the ACL grow back?

No. Once the ACL is completely torn, it does not grow back. Sometimes the torn ligament scars back to the bone in an abnormal position, but it then does not stabilise the knee like a normal ACL. The most common ACL operation is a reconstruction, in which a graft replaces the torn ligament.

Can you live without an ACL?

Yes. Although the ACL is important for controlling rotation and front-to-back movement, many people live productive, active lives without ACL surgery, particularly if they do not play pivoting sports.

Can you put weight on a knee with a torn ACL?

After an ACL injury, the diagnosis should be confirmed with an examination and an MRI scan. Once an ACL injury is confirmed, you can usually put weight on the leg. Crutches are often helpful for the first one to two weeks.

What should you do after an ACL injury?

If you injure your knee, crutches, ice and anti-inflammatory medication (if suitable for you) can help until you see a doctor. Keeping weight off the knee helps in the early stages, and a compression bandage, such as Tubigrip, can help with swelling. Some people find a straight knee brace helps with pain in the first week.

Your doctor will examine your knee and may arrange an X-ray if a fracture is possible. If an ACL injury is suspected, you will usually be referred for an MRI scan and to an orthopaedic surgeon. Early range-of-motion exercises help prevent stiffness.

Seeing a physiotherapist early is worthwhile whether or not you have surgery. The early goals are to control swelling, regain movement and strengthen the muscles around the knee.

Two MRI scans of the knee: a normal ACL appears as a dark stripe on the left, and a torn ACL appears indistinct on the right.
MRI showing a normal ACL (left) and a complete ACL tear (right). The normal ACL is a dark stripe; the torn ACL looks indistinct.

Which is worse, an ACL or an MCL injury?

ACL and MCL (medial collateral ligament) injuries are treated differently but can occur together. MCL injuries are the most common knee ligament injury and usually happen when the knee is forced inwards. Most heal on their own without long-term problems. Occasionally the ligament is completely torn and the knee is unstable, and surgery may be needed.

ACL injuries usually happen during pivoting or sudden changes of direction, often without contact. The same forces can also tear the MCL, so combined injuries are common.

When ACL surgery is planned with an MCL injury, two issues arise. The first is graft choice: the hamstrings help stabilise the inner side of the knee, so using them as the graft may leave more laxity on that side. Alternatives include the quadriceps tendon, the patellar tendon or hamstrings from the other leg. The second is that a partially torn MCL should be allowed to heal first, because an MCL that heals loosely may strain the new ACL graft. For this reason, the knee is often braced for about six weeks before an ACL reconstruction, if one is needed.

What happens if an ACL injury is not treated with surgery?

Not everyone with an ACL injury needs surgery. The ACL is particularly important for younger, active people (under about 25), because it helps protect the meniscus, which in turn protects the cartilage. It is also important for people of any age who play pivoting or cutting sports, such as soccer, AFL or netball. If you mainly do straight-line activities or low-demand work, non-surgical treatment with rehabilitation may be suitable.

People who may benefit from earlier ACL surgery include:

  • young, active people (under about 25)
  • people with an ACL rupture and an unstable, repairable meniscus tear
  • people who regularly play pivoting or cutting sports.

If you choose non-surgical treatment, an experienced sports physiotherapist can help you regain movement, thigh muscle bulk and balance so you can compensate for the missing ACL. After a 4–6 month trial of physiotherapy, your knee should be reassessed. If it is still unstable, ACL surgery can be reconsidered.

How long does an ACL tear take to heal without surgery?

Complete ACL tears usually occur in the middle of the ligament, which has a poor blood supply, so the chance of it healing and working properly is very small. A true partial tear may take around four months to heal, after which the knee’s stability should be reassessed and further imaging may be needed. In selected people, non-surgical management can work well.

What are the long-term effects of a torn ACL?

A complete ACL tear can lead to further damage to the meniscus, the shock absorber of the knee. The meniscus then carries load less effectively, which increases pressure on the cartilage and may speed up arthritis. People with an ACL rupture have been reported to be about four times more likely to develop knee osteoarthritis.

Can you strengthen your knee without an ACL?

Yes. Everyone with an ACL injury should see a physiotherapist soon after the injury. Whether or not you have surgery, strengthening the muscles around the knee helps you compensate for the injury.

How can you prevent an ACL injury?

ACL injury prevention programs include dynamic warm-ups, strength training for the core, hips and thighs, technique training and plyometrics (jumping exercises). Following these programs can reduce the risk of ACL injury. The main elements are:

  • warm-up and stretching
  • strengthening
  • balance
  • agility
  • jump-landing training
  • adequate rest.

For more information, see the FIFA 11+ injury prevention program or the KNEE program from Netball Australia.

Can you play sport without an ACL?

The ACL controls rapid changes of direction (cutting) and twisting (pivoting). Many sports, including rugby, AFL, netball and basketball, involve these movements, which can be difficult after an ACL injury. Strengthening the thigh muscles can partly compensate, but returning to your previous level may be difficult. Activities such as jogging, running and some skiing involve less cutting and pivoting and may be possible without ACL surgery.

What does ACL surgery involve?

Is it bad to wait for ACL surgery?

Dr Vishal Pai generally aims to operate around 4–6 weeks after the injury. Operating earlier, while the knee is still swollen and stiff, increases the risk of stiffness after surgery. Waiting much longer allows ongoing instability to damage the meniscus.

How do you prepare for ACL surgery?

Seeing a physiotherapist before surgery, often called prehabilitation, helps you regain movement, reduce swelling and strengthen the thigh muscles. The better prepared you are, the easier your rehabilitation is likely to be.

How long does ACL surgery take?

An ACL reconstruction takes about an hour. It can take up to two hours if additional procedures are needed, such as repairing a complex meniscal tear or adding an anterolateral (outer side) reconstruction.

Which graft should you have for ACL surgery?

The three main grafts are the hamstrings, the patellar tendon and the quadriceps tendon. Each has advantages and disadvantages, which you should discuss with your surgeon. A summary is below.

Hamstring graft. This is the most common graft in Australia. Two hamstring tendons (semitendinosus and gracilis) are taken through a small incision on the inner side of the leg. The early recovery is generally easier, and the incision is smaller than for a patellar tendon graft. Disadvantages include a slightly higher rate of infection and re-rupture than a patellar tendon graft, hamstring weakness and unpredictable graft size. Graft size is linked to re-rupture risk, and a diameter of more than 8 mm is ideal in an average-sized person.

Patellar tendon graft. This is a good choice for many athletes. The surgeon can choose the graft size, and the bone plugs at each end heal quickly into the bone tunnels. The incision is larger and pain at the front of the knee is more common, but the patellar tendon has the lowest re-rupture rate of the three main grafts.

Quadriceps tendon graft. This option is being used more often. It is strong, needs only a small incision, and its size can be chosen by the surgeon. One registry-based study reported a slightly higher re-rupture rate than other grafts, although this has not been consistently shown in other studies. You can read more in Quadriceps Tendon Graft for ACL Reconstruction.

Is ACL surgery major or minor surgery?

ACL reconstruction is a common operation with a generally low complication rate, although risks include infection, stiffness, blood clots and graft failure. It is technically demanding but not usually considered major surgery. For you, though, it is a major undertaking because of the long rehabilitation that follows. Committing to good-quality rehabilitation is key to a successful result.

Diagram of an ACL reconstruction, showing a tendon graft passing through tunnels in the thighbone and shin bone.
An ACL reconstruction

Can your ACL tear be repaired?

ACL surgery involves either reconstructing the torn ACL, which is most common, or repairing it. Repair is only suitable when the ACL has torn away from its attachment on the thighbone, which can be seen on MRI, and the ligament tissue is in good condition. It can be done up to 3 months after the injury, but within 4 weeks is preferable, before the torn ligament shrinks. The advantage is that no graft is needed. The disadvantage is that about 1 in 10 repairs fail, and failure is more common in younger people, so repair is generally not the preferred option for them. Some people later need a reconstruction because of ongoing instability. Read more about ACL repair.

How long is the public waiting list for ACL surgery?

It depends on the hospital, the surgeon and any other injuries. People who also have a meniscal tear causing a locked knee that will not straighten are treated more urgently, because this can damage the meniscus and cartilage further. Most people with an ACL injury alone are placed in Category 3, with surgery intended within 365 days of joining the waiting list.

How much does ACL surgery cost privately without insurance?

Most surgeons work in both the public and private sectors, and the quality of surgery does not differ. Waiting times are longer in the public system, which is why some people consider private surgery.

Private costs include fees for the surgeon, assistant, anaesthetist, hospital and implants, plus radiology and physiotherapy. For a hamstring graft ACL reconstruction, the estimated total is about $13,100–$13,600 before any Medicare rebate, and more if a meniscus is repaired at the same time. A formal quote is provided after your consultation, once the details of your surgery are known. See the ACL surgery cost information sheet (PDF) and How Much Does Private Knee Surgery Cost if You Are Uninsured?

Will your private insurance cover ACL surgery?

Policies differ, so check with your health fund whether ACL surgery is covered. You can ask whether your policy covers the commonly used item number 49542.

How successful is ACL surgery?

Success depends on how you measure it. In athletes, success often means returning to sport. Some people have a stable knee after surgery but do not return to sport, and psychological factors such as fear of re-injury, as well as motivation, play a part. Studies report that about 50–70% of younger patients return to sport. Even so, many people are satisfied with their surgery because their knee is more stable and functions better.

What is rehabilitation like after ACL surgery?

What should you do after ACL surgery?

Start rehabilitation with a sports physiotherapist. In the first few weeks, the goals are to reduce swelling, improve movement and start activating the thigh muscles.

Ice can help with pain and swelling. A common approach is about 20 minutes of ice, followed by at least 40–60 minutes off, and keeping ice away from the outer side of the knee just below the joint, where a nerve lies close to the skin. A cold compression device, such as Game Ready or CryoCuff, may improve comfort early on.

Avoid doing too much too soon. Increased swelling is a common sign of overload, and pushing too hard can delay your rehabilitation. Your physiotherapist will guide your exercise, and you will be given a rehabilitation protocol.

Two people doing squat exercises on wooden boxes in a gym.
Rehabilitation builds strength and control over many months

How long is rehabilitation after ACL surgery?

Rehabilitation takes a minimum of 12 months after surgery.

What is the fastest way to recover from ACL surgery?

A good recovery depends on well-performed surgery, supervised rehabilitation and following the restrictions after surgery. Your body breaks down the graft and rebuilds it to act as an ACL, and much of this happens within 12 months, which is why sport should be avoided during this phase. There is no way to speed up this healing. At around 12 months, your physiotherapist will test your strength, muscle bulk and balance before you return to competitive sport. People who pass return to play testing have a lower risk of re-injury. You can read more in Return to Play Testing After ACL Reconstruction.

How long does it take to recover from ACL surgery?

To reduce the risk of re-rupture, competitive sport should be avoided for at least 12 months after surgery. After that, your return depends on your strength, muscle bulk and balance, which your physiotherapist will test. For a stage-by-stage guide to what you can expect after surgery, see ACL reconstruction recovery week by week.

Why is ACL recovery so long?

The graft is placed in bone tunnels in the thighbone (femur) and shin bone (tibia) and needs to heal to the bone, which takes about 6–12 weeks depending on the graft. Your body also breaks down and rebuilds the graft so it can work as an ACL, a process called ligamentisation. Most of this takes about 12 months, which is why recovery is long.

How long will you need crutches after ACL surgery?

Crutches are usually needed for about two to three weeks. They reduce the load on the knee and make it more comfortable to get around.

When can you walk after ACL surgery?

After an ACL reconstruction, you can usually put weight on the leg straight away. The exception is if the meniscus has been repaired at the same time, when you may need to use crutches and avoid putting weight on the leg for about six weeks.

When can you squat after ACL surgery?

Rehabilitation is based on meeting criteria rather than fixed dates. The main goals of the first one to two weeks are to reduce swelling, improve movement and activate the thigh muscles. Once these are achieved, squats and other resistance exercises can be introduced.

Can you climb stairs after ACL surgery?

Yes. A physiotherapist will check that you can use stairs safely before you go home. Take care when moving around after surgery to avoid re-injuring your knee.

Will your knee ever be the same after ACL surgery?

ACL surgery reduces the feeling of instability and aims to help you return to sport and activity. Because your original ligament is replaced with a graft, your knee may feel different, but most people adjust over time. The final result can take 12–18 months, and many people are satisfied by this stage.

Is it easy to re-tear the ACL after surgery?

Technical factors in the surgery are a common cause of graft failure. The risk of re-injury is lower when surgery uses a good graft, well-positioned tunnels and appropriate treatment of any other injuries. Surgery also needs to be combined with supervised rehabilitation from an experienced sports physiotherapist. Returning to sport before you are physically ready increases the risk of re-injury.

How do you know if your ACL graft has failed?

A graft re-injury usually follows a specific incident and feels like a pop or tear. The knee swells, and the feeling of instability may return. See a knee specialist for assessment, and an MRI may be needed to confirm a re-injury. This is very disappointing, but revision surgery can achieve good results.

How often does an ACL graft fail?

Reported failure rates are often under 5% on average, but the risk depends on factors such as your age, activity level and the type of graft, and it is higher in young athletes returning to pivoting sport.

Is it common to tear your ACL twice?

Tearing the same ACL graft again is uncommon, with an average risk often reported under 5%. However, people who have torn one ACL have a much higher risk, about 8–16%, of tearing the ACL in the other knee.

Is the ACL graft stronger than the original?

In laboratory testing, ACL grafts can withstand more force before failing than the native ACL. One biomechanical study reported these average loads to failure:

  • native ACL: 1,725 N (newtons of force)
  • quadrupled hamstring graft: 4,000 N
  • patellar tendon graft: 2,977 N
  • quadriceps tendon graft: 2,352 N.

However, a graft in the knee does not exactly replicate the original ACL. Even though it may be stronger, it can still fail with a significant injury.

Why do ACL allografts fail more often?

Allograft tissue comes from a deceased donor and contains no living cells, so it acts as a scaffold. Your own cells need to grow into it, which takes much longer than with your own tissue (an autograft). Allografts are also sterilised to prevent infection, which can weaken them. Allograft ACL reconstructions fail at a higher rate, so in most situations they are not recommended.

Will a LARS synthetic ligament speed up your recovery?

LARS is a synthetic ligament designed to avoid harvesting a graft and to allow a faster return to sport, quoted as 3–4 months. It was later found to have a higher failure rate and to cause inflammation of the joint lining (synovitis). For these reasons, it is not recommended for ACL reconstruction.

What happens if you return to sport early?

Returning to competitive sport earlier than recommended increases the risk of rupturing your ACL graft. One study found that returning to sport before nine months after surgery was associated with a higher re-injury rate, and that each month of delay up to nine months reduced the re-injury rate by about half.

Summary

An ACL injury is a significant setback, but with the right treatment many people return to an active life. Whether you need surgery depends on your age, activities and any other knee injuries. If you have surgery, the graft choice and a committed 12-month rehabilitation program are key to a good result.

If you would like to discuss how this applies to your knee, you can book a consultation with Dr Vishal Pai.

Would you like to discuss your ACL injury?

Dr Vishal Pai treats ACL injuries and performs ACL reconstruction. You can arrange a consultation to discuss your injury, whether surgery may suit you and what recovery involves.

Dr Vishal Pai

Written by Dr Vishal Pai

Knee Surgeon, Melbourne

Vishal is an experienced knee surgeon based in Bayside, Melbourne. He consults at Sandringham Orthopaedic Specialists and operates at The Avenue Hospital and Calvary Holmesglen Private Hospital. His practice focuses on sports knee surgery, including ACL reconstruction and meniscal repair, as well as robotic knee replacement.

More about Dr Pai  →

Dr Vishal Pai’s newsletter

His newsletter brings you evidence-based information on common knee conditions and their treatment, along with his latest articles.

We’ll send you an email to confirm your subscription. You can unsubscribe at any time. Our privacy policy explains how we handle your details.

The ACL Injury Guide: Your Questions Answered
Scroll to top